
1. 4 MONTHS, 3 WEEKS & 2 DAYS (Cristian Mungiu)
A teenaged girl in Soviet Romania seeks an illegal abortion (the title refers to how far she is in her pregnancy). Her roommate gets her a secret appointment in a hotel room with a sleazy, manipulative doctor, who puts both girls through humiliation. Writer-director Cristian Mungiu doesn’t editorialize (this movie isn’t explicitly “pro-life” or “pro-choice”), but just observes the situation in a way that, I’m forced to conclude, it probably would have happened. It’s a challenging film that is about as minimalist as you can get – no music, natural lighting, handheld camera - but it has a strong sense of immediacy, as if it were surveillance footage unfolding in the present tense. Winner of the Palme d’Or at this year’s Cannes Film Festival, and the most powerful movie I saw all year.

2. NO COUNTRY FOR OLD MEN (Joel Coen, Ethan Coen)
The Coen Brothers have always been unpredictable filmmakers willing to experiment with different styles – there’s not much that links Fargo, The Big Lebowski, The Man Who Wasn’t There, and Intolerable Cruelty other than the Coen’s particular brand of quirky humour. But No Country for Old Men is the first of the Coen’s movies that might not pass a DNA test: a singularly tense, suspenseful, austere, and tight thriller. It’s also perhaps their best movie (even if I feel Fargo breathing down my neck). Very tense and entertaining, and virtually flawless writing, directing, and performances.

3. AWAY FROM HER (Sarah Polley)
In the actress Sarah Polley’s directorial debut, a long-married couple played (perfectly) by Gordon Pinsent and Julie Christie are dealt a blow when Christie is diagnosed with Alzheimer’s, and she agrees to move into a nursing home. After only a month, Pinsent returns to visit Christie in the Alzheimer’s home to find that not only does she not remember who he is, but that she has fallen in love with another one of the patients. Considering his infidelities over the years, is this some kind of poetic justice? This movie is real heartbreaker, but also deeply warm and human. As mature a directorial debut as you’re likely to find.

4. PARIS, JE T’AIME (Various)
“Enchanting” isn’t a word I throw around very often, but that’s exactly what this very charming anthology film is. 18 short films by 20 of the world’s most interesting directors, all of them loosely about love in Paris. Of course, some are better than other, but at five minutes apiece, there are no real misfires, and they’re all unmistakably of a piece. Highlights include segments by the Coen Brothers, Vincenzo Natali, Tom Tykwer, and Sylvian Chomet, but far and away the pick of the litter is the conclusion by Alexander Payne, with Margo Martindale as a middle aged American tourist with an atrocious accent who has been saving up for her trip to Paris for years. I can’t quite put into words why this final scene is so good, but it combines humour and pathos in such a note-perfect way that it made Paris, je t’aime one of the few movies to actually make me really cry. And I’m man enough to admit it.
(Interesting news: this may go down as the unlikeliest 2007 film to inspire a sequel. Tentatively scheduled for 2008 is New York, I Love You, with contributions by Mira Nair, Park Chan-wook, Brett Ratner, and Jason Reitman, among others).

5. BEFORE THE DEVIL KNOWS YOU’RE DEAD (Sidney Lumet)
If Away from Her felt like the work of a veteran, 83-year-old Sidney Lumet’s Before the Devil Knows You’re Dead feels like it was directed by someone a quarter his age. A crime thriller about a heist gone wrong sounds like standard material, but Lumet’s timeline-shifting narrative structure and the performances by Philip Seymour Hoffman, Ethan Hawke, and Albert Finney make it completely engrossing. Watching this, I felt that same way I felt when I saw Fargo and Pulp Fiction for the first time: being absorbed by an unpredictable plot unfolding. One of Lumet’s very best…which puts it in the same company as 12 Angry Men and Dog Day Afternoon.

6. BATTLE FOR HADITHA (Nick Broomfield)
The great documentary filmmaker Nick Broomfield (Aileen Wuornos: The Selling of a Serial Killer; Heidi Fleiss: Hollywood Madam) has been making a transition into fiction filmmaking, and with Battle for Haditha he made one of his most impressive achievements in any genre. It’s a torn-from-the-headlines story (so torn-from-the-headlines that the real events haven’t even been settled in court yet!) about four United States soldiers in Iraq who allegedly killed 24 Iraqis – men, women, children – after one of their fellow soldiers was killed by a bomb. Broomfield films the violent scenes with brutal intensity and a sense of blunt realism that only a documentary filmmaker could achieve (there are times when the film is virtually indistinguishable from news footage), but what really makes this great is Broomfield’s refusal to turn any of his characters into villains. This played at the Toronto Film Festival but has not yet received theatrical release; forgive me for jumping the gun.

7. THE KING OF KONG: A FISTFUL OF QUARTERS (Seth Gordon)
In the grand tradition of the Red Sox against the Yankees and Ali against Foreman comes Steve Wiebe and Billy Mitchell, two grown men who are competing for…the world record score in Donkey Kong. Sure, there are laughs to be had over the weight the people in this film bring to the competition – there are times when this is virtually indistinguishable from one of those Christopher Guest mockumentaries (wait’ll you see Mitchell’s geeky disciples). But The King of Kong is a wonderful movie not because of any cheap laughs it scores against its subjects but because of its depiction of two men – the decent family man Wiebe and the arrogant, Machiavellian Mitchell – whose only real distinction is their video game proficiency, and the lengths that they will go to in order to keep their names in the record books.

8. NO END IN SIGHT (Charles Ferguson)
Arguably the best of the many documentaries about the Iraq war, No End in Sight is also one of the most uncompromisingly bleak. Not a ‘liberal’ film, per se, but rather a calm, non-partisan tallying of the Bush’s administrations many tactical blunders in the handling of the Iraq reconstruction process, with particular emphasis placed on their stupefying decision to disband the Iraqi military. The cumulative effect of this film is devastating, and unlike other wake-up-call documentaries like Darfur Now and An Inconvenient Truth, the filmmakers offer no audience-congratulating silver lining.

9. RED ROAD (Andrea Arnold)
A surveillance monitor operator notices a man on one of the screens who looks familiar. Slowly she begins stalking him, showing up unannounced at his parties and following him to bars until he begins to notice and lust after her. She is apparently interested in revenge, but revenge for what? Details are revealed slowly, and the big picture doesn’t become clear until near the end in this dread-inducing, extremely tense Scottish film, the winner of the Jury Prize at Cannes. Compulsively fascinating viewing.

10. LUST, CAUTION (Ang Lee)
A somewhat arbitrary choice for number ten, I picked Lust, Caution ahead of the honourable mentions because it’s the one that has stuck with me the most. In Japanese-occupied China, an inexperienced girl (Tang Wei) finds herself in a resistance movement and is assigned the task of seducing and murdering a Chinese power-player (Tony Leung Chiu-wai, from 2046) who is in cahoots with the Japanese. After some false starts, she finally becomes Leung’s mistress, but once the relationship becomes sexual, a strange, sadomasochistic bond forms between them. I wasn’t raving about this when I came out of it, but over the last few months it has lingered in my memory because of its careful structure, slowly building up tension for almost two hours before the final, very powerful last forty minutes. Tony Leung gives a very disturbing performance that may be the best of his career, and Tang Wei matches him in her debut performance. And of course, there are the much talked-about, NC-17 rated sex scenes, which are shockingly explicit but form the film’s emotional (or, more truthfully, queasily un-emotional) centre. Another strong piece of work from Ang Lee, whose filmography has been varied enough to also include Brokeback Mountain, The Hulk, and Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon.
TIED FOR 11TH PLACE
The Diving Bell and the Butterfly – A film that literally puts the viewer in the body of a paralyzed stroke victim. A challenging but surprisingly uplifting film, and an incredible achievement for director Julian Schnabel.
Gone Baby Gone – A powerful and thought-provoking directorial debut for Ben Affleck.
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix – The darkest and most thrilling of the Potter series, and the first one to justify its existence as a great work of entertainment in its own right, not a slavish cash-in on J.K. Rowling’s books.
In the Shadow of the Moon – A genuinely awe-inspiring documentary that breathes vivid new life into the old Apollo footage.
The Lives of Others – Oscar-winner for Best Foreign Film, with a great performance by the late Ulrich Muhe. I defy you not to tear up at the last scene.
Once – A really wonderful low-budget Irish romance/musical.
Paprika – A completely unique piece of anime from Satoshi Konn. Scene for scene, more amazing images than any other movie this year.
28 Weeks Later – The sequel to 28 Days Later is everything a serious horror film should be: smart, intense, bleak, and scary.
Ratatouille – Another hugely entertaining Pixar movie. The early kitchen scene, where the camera takes the point-of-view of the rat, is as good a scene as Pixar has ever made.
Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street – Tim Burton’s most virtuoso work in some time.